CCBC

The ‘why’ of suffering – 30 April 2023

I’ve been listening this past week to some sermons on the theme of suffering. Our typical, immediate response to suffering is to ask “why?” – “why is this happening to me / my family?” – and then perhaps “why isn’t God doing anything about this? / why isn’t He hearing my prayers?”

Now, have you ever noticed that in the most profound, intense Bible book on suffering, God never answers Job’s ‘why?’ questions? In fact, in chapters 38-41 God actually asks Job a succession of questions which he is unable to answer! Although Job is given no explanation for all his suffering, God does wonderfully affirm him, declaring twice that Job has spoken of God “what is right” (42v7,8), including, therefore, his ‘why?’ questions.

The ‘innocent’ Job points forward to the only truly innocent Man, Jesus Christ, who suffered in the greatest ever, indeed unimaginable ways as He died on the cross. And remarkably He also asked “why?” – and He also didn’t receive an answer from God. When He cried out “My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?”, God remained silent.

Doesn’t God care? Is He perverse? Why doesn’t He answer? We firmly believe that He does care and that He’s not perverse, even if at times we’re only ‘just hanging on’. He may intervene miraculously to end our suffering (and we can and must pray for this) – but He may not, and we may not get an explanation. But ultimately we will understand.

In Hebrews 12v2 the author talks about Jesus, “Who for the joy set before Him endured the cross”. The apostle Paul describes our present sufferings as “light and momentary troubles [that] are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all” (2 Corinthians 4v17). Consequently and significantly, the author of Hebrews tells us to “fix our eyes on Jesus”, whilst Paul says “we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen”.

The issue then is not God’s answer to our “why?” questions, but our answer to the “what?” and “Who?” questions – what / Who are we fixing our eyes on, and Who indeed do we trust? When God says that His will is “good, pleasing and perfect” (Romans 12v2) and that “in all things God works for the good of those who love Him”, do we believe Him?

Peace and Grace

Paul